Many Android enthusiasts in the US have eagerly been awaiting the opportunity to obtain smartphones from up-and-coming Chinese manufacturer Huawei through their carrier. We were expecting a confirmation at CES 2018 that AT&T would sell Huawei devices, but the deal seems to have fallen through due to political pressure from the US government.
It's no secret that Huawei is trying to crack the US market, and it is already possible for stateside customers to obtain several select models unlocked. But if the brand really wants to make it into the mainstream, it needs to strike a deal with carriers that can offer their phones through a contract.
At the end of last year, it seemed like a done deal that Huawei's first official American carrier would be AT&T, offering the Huawei Mate 10. We were expecting this to be officially announced at CES 2018, but in the end it looks like the deal has been stopped by the US government, citing concerns of Chinese espionage.
According to The Information, a letter dating December 20 from a committee of the US Senate accuses Huawei of links with the Chinese Communist Party and its secret services: "Our committee's further findings on this matter have only strengthened concerns over the espionage of Huawei and China,". As a consequence, AT&T cancelled the deal.
This comes as a major blow to Huawei's American ambitions, as manufacturers who cannot offer their phones through providers such AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile and Verizon cannot hope to become household names. For Huawei, the AT&T deal was also a prestige project to shore up their reputation as a premium manufacturer, leading with their Mate 10 Pro flagship.
Do Chinese smartphones pose a security risk to the US?
Previously, US authorities had accused Huawei and other Chinese manufacturers of spying on behalf of the Chinese government. However, these accusations have not been proven, and Huawei has always denied any ties to Chinese espionage. Nonetheless, the US government is concerned enough to put pressure on American carriers not to offer Huawei devices.
This hardline stance and lack of trust may simply be an indication of the current administration's 'America first' nationalism. Certainly, President Trump has made no secret of his suspicion of China ever since his campaign, and this hasn't helped relations between the two powers.
It would be naive to think that our data isn't being collected by the devices that we use, and corporations can be quite sneaky about their spying—just look at what happened with OnePlus. Of course, this isn't a phenomenon exclusive to Chinese companies. US tech giants such as Google and Facebook also make their fortune gathering user data.
Everyone knows that this data is ostensibly used by corporations for market research and targeted advertising, but it can also be used by political organisations, for example, to target propaganda during elections. The question here is, would Huawei sell the user data to the Chinese Communist Party?
The average user might not be too concerned where their data is going, whether it is to private companies, their own government, or a foreign one. One thing's for sure though, as a consequence of this political intrigue, stateside consumers will miss out on some pretty good smartphones in the name of national security.
Huawei is ready to compete in the US, but is held back by politics
Huawei has undergone an enormous rise in recent years. Since entering the end-customer market under its own brand in 2011, Huawei has made it to third place behind Apple and Samsung, and has at times even taken second place. However, Huawei will probably only be satisfied when they have reached the top—and this will hardly be possible without the US market.
Huawei's entry to the US market would be beneficial for consumers.
What do you think?
Here at AndroidPIT, we've generally been impressed with the quality of Huawei's phones. Their arrival to the US market could have disrupted the complacency of other premium manufacturers, which are generally following Apple's lead in driving prices ever higher, breaking the $1000 mark.
Huawei has already made a brief statement on the matter: "In the last five years, Huawei has proven that we offer first-class equipment worldwide and on the US market. On Tuesday we will introduce new products for the US market, including details of their availability. Further information will follow shortly."
It looks like Huawei has yet to give up on their American dream, so it remains to be seen what will come of this.
What do you think? Is the US government justified in its suspicion of Huawei? Or is this completely unfair to US consumers?